Persevering with a yearslong pattern, President Donald Trump made false and deceptive feedback about new auto crops in Michigan, and the trade at giant — boasting in current marketing campaign rallies about accomplishments that aren’t true.
- Trump claimed his entreaties to the prime minister of Japan led to the announcement of “5 crops” in Michigan. There have been 5 new investments — not “crops” — by Japanese automobile firms since 2017; considered one of them is a producing facility for gas cells, not an auto meeting plant.
- The president falsely claimed there hadn’t been a brand new auto plant inbuilt “40 years.” Volvo and Mercedes-Benz each introduced new crops in 2015.
- He claimed that automobile manufacturing and gross sales had been “file setting.” Neither is at file ranges, and annual figures present manufacturing and gross sales have dropped since 2016 underneath Trump.
The variety of motorcar and elements manufacturing jobs in Michigan has gone down — not up — underneath Trump, even earlier than the coronavirus pandemic precipitated financial shutdowns.
In a rally in Fayetteville, North Carolina, on Sept. 19 and one other in Vandalia, Ohio, on Sept. 21, Trump instructed a narrative about asking Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (who lately resigned) for Japanese automobile firms to construct crops within the U.S., claiming, “Subsequent day, it was a narrative, ‘5 automobile firms to open up in Michigan.’”
Right here’s the model Trump instructed on the Sept. 21 rally:
Vandalia, Ohio, rally Sept. 21: You know the way many automobile crops we’re bringing again to Michigan? No one’s ever seen it. For 40 years, they didn’t construct a plant. And now they’re constructing them throughout. And I inform international locations, I instructed an awesome gentleman, he simply retired, Prime Minister Abe of Japan. I mentioned, “Shinzo, you bought to construct crops right here, you possibly can’t do that. You’re constructing your vehicles in Japan and sending them. We wish our vehicles constructed right here. We wish vehicles constructed right here.” He mentioned, “Nicely, that’s lower than me, that’s as much as the corporate.” “That’s all proper, Shinzo, I do know you are able to do it.” The following day they introduced 5 crops, I imply, what can I inform you?
The president is incorrect on two counts: Japanese automobile firms didn’t announce 5 new crops in Michigan, and auto crops have certainly been constructed within the U.S. prior to now 40 years.
Trump additionally instructed a crowd in Freeland, Michigan, on Sept. 10 this story in regards to the “5 automobile firms … coming to Michigan,” and claimed that “you haven’t had a plant inbuilt like 42 years.”
If he meant to confer with solely auto manufacturing crops inbuilt Michigan, he’s incorrect on that, too. Previous to 2017, when Trump took workplace, Common Motors constructed a lightweight automobile meeting plant in Lansing Delta Township, accomplished in 2006. It’s “GM’s latest plant in america,” the corporate’s web site says.
That’s the newest mild automobile meeting plant constructed within the state previous to 2017, when Trump took workplace, in accordance with Kristin Dziczek, vice chairman of trade, labor & economics on the Middle for Automotive Analysis.
CAR is a Michigan-based analysis group that receives a few of its funding from the federal authorities and tracks auto trade investments in North America.
In Ohio, Dziczek mentioned, the newest mild automobile meeting plant was accomplished in 2005: a Fiat Chrysler Cars plant to construct the Jeep Wrangler and Wrangler Limitless in Toledo.
Trump has made comparable claims earlier than, equivalent to when he mentioned in June 2019, naming a number of states, “They hadn’t constructed one [an auto plant] in many years and now they’re all over.” Two new crops had been introduced in 2015 in South Carolina — by Volvo, which broke floor on the plant on Sept. 25, 2015, and by Mercedes-Benz, which broke floor in July 2016.
As for brand spanking new crops since Trump took workplace, CAR instructed us then that it knew of solely two new meeting crops: a Toyota/Mazda three way partnership plant in Alabama (introduced in January 2018) and a Fiat Chrysler Cars plant in Michigan (introduced in February 2019).
We requested CAR about Trump’s current declare concerning 5 new Japanese crops in Michigan. Dziczek instructed us there have been 5 new investments by Japanese automakers in Michigan, however solely considered one of them is a producing facility, which was introduced on Jan. 30, 2017, simply 10 days after Trump took workplace.
And it’s not an auto meeting plant to construct vehicles, as Trump’s feedback recommend.
Honda and Common Motors introduced the three way partnership to supply hydrogen gas cell techniques in GM’s current Brownstone, Michigan, battery pack manufacturing facility. The businesses mentioned in a press launch they might make investments a mixed $85 million within the challenge, which might create almost 100 jobs. Honda and GM had been working collectively to create gas cell techniques underneath a collaboration settlement they unveiled in July 2013.
As for the opposite 4 investments in Michigan:
- Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi introduced in June 2017 that it had put in two new electrical automobile fast-charge stations in Southeastern Michigan;
- Toyota mentioned in Might 2018 it could broaden an autonomous automobile testing facility;
- Subaru introduced in August 2018 a $48 million funding in a know-how heart that will create 100 jobs;
- Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi proposed in June 2019 increasing its North American Tech Middle at a value of $41 million. It might create 85 jobs, Dziczek instructed us.
We requested the Trump marketing campaign for assist for the president’s statements, however we haven’t acquired a response.
Even when Trump meant to say new “investments” as an alternative of “crops,” the Michigan investments throughout his time in workplace are lower than what Japanese firms had invested in the three prior years in 2014 to 2016.
Dziczek mentioned there have been 11 investments by Japanese firms in Michigan over that 2014-2016 time-frame in expansions, new services and retooling of an current facility. These investments totaled $315.3 million and concerned greater than 2,529 jobs (with no data on jobs for 3 of the investments).
Throughout Trump’s tenure, there have been $174.2 million in investments involving 285 jobs (with no data on the funding or jobs for the automobile charging stations or the autonomous automobile testing facility).
Whereas Trump has made false boasts about auto crops in Michigan, the variety of jobs in automobiles and elements manufacturing within the state has dropped underneath his watch. As of February, earlier than the pandemic shutdowns started, motorcar and elements manufacturing jobs had fallen by 2,400 from January 2017, when Trump took workplace, in accordance with the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
As of August, these Michigan jobs stood at 155,800, down 18,400 from the month Trump was inaugurated.
Nationwide, motor automobiles and elements manufacturing jobs have gone up underneath Trump, however the job progress was quicker underneath the Obama administration. That’s wanting on the pre-pandemic numbers. From January 2017 to February 2020, 49,300 auto manufacturing jobs had been added, a 5.2% progress price. Throughout the identical time interval — 37 months — on the finish of the Obama administration, motor automobiles and elements manufacturing jobs grew by 99,600, or 11.6%.
Manufacturing and Gross sales Not a ‘Document’
The president additionally claimed that auto gross sales and manufacturing had been setting data, however neither is at file ranges.
Trump, Sept. 21: Automobile manufacturing is file setting. You check out automobile gross sales are file setting.
Knowledge from the Bureau of Financial Evaluation present that neither home manufacturing nor mild weight automobile gross sales are at file ranges. The newest figures are for July and August, respectively.
On a yearly foundation, each manufacturing and gross sales have been decrease underneath Trump’s presidency than they had been in 2016, the yr earlier than he took workplace.
In 2016, 3.9 million models had been assembled within the U.S. That determine has dropped yearly since and stood at 2.5 million models in 2019.
As for gross sales, these too had been larger in 2016 — 209.6 million models — than any yr thus far underneath Trump. Gentle automobile gross sales had been 203.4 million in 2019.
Dziczek shared with us figures that embody gross sales of medium responsibility automobiles. These additionally confirmed 2016 with larger gross sales than any yr since.
It’s attainable Trump was referring to the tempo of restoration for manufacturing and gross sales, after each plummeted in March and April throughout financial shutdowns because of the coronavirus pandemic. Each measures have almost recovered to February ranges. But when that’s a file restoration, it was solely attainable after manufacturing fell by 99.2% from February to April and lightweight automobile gross sales dropped 47.8%.
Eugene Kiely contributed to this text.
Editor’s word: Swing State Watch is an occasional sequence about false and deceptive political messages in key states that can assist resolve the 2020 presidential election.
Editor’s Word: Please contemplate a donation to FactCheck.org. We don’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from individuals such as you. Bank card donations could also be made by way of our “Donate” web page. In case you choose to provide by test, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Middle, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
This truth test is accessible at IFCN’s 2020 US Elections FactChat #Chatbot on WhatsApp. Click on right here for extra.